Making rare earth materials as sustainable as possible

Rare earth magnets are increasing in demand as we shift to a zero-carbon economy, and electric vehicles especially use a lot of magnets. Currently, less than 1% of these magnets are actually recycled, so as the demand for them increases, as does the scale of extraction and processing of the rare earth materials, which is creating huge environmental issues.

RaRE is a project underway at Advanced Electric Machines that has set out to answer: how do we extract rare earth materials from waste electronics and recycle them back into magnets to be used in motors, and do we do this in a sustainable way? 

Why?

There are a considerable number of individual magnets in the non-drive mechanisms in a car. Many of these magnets are tiny, so they cannot easily be replaced with magnet-free technology. The question then becomes, how do we make these irreplaceable magnets as sustainable as possible?

For all the time and effort invested, recycling rare earth materials has been broadly unsuccessful. The current process is to either melt magnets back to a master alloy or use solvent extraction to extract rare earth materials. Not only are these processes energy-intensive, but they also require magnets to be separate from other components in the motor housing, which often isn’t the case. With a limited supply available, manufacturers are looking for a more practical and cost-effective way of operating systems using magnet-based technology.

Working with the leader in magnet recycling and manufacturing, HyProMag, and the University of Birmingham, our goal is to broaden the range of scrap for the extraction of magnets and scale-up the extraction and recycling processes to make as many motor technologies as sustainable as possible.

The recycled magnets will be used in the bespoke ancillary motors designed and manufactured by AEM, and applied by Bentley Motors. Unipart will then develop a scalable manufacturing route for the volume production of this design. 

The Opportunities

There are currently no motor designs on the market using recycled rare earth materials. Aside from making this an industry first, there are broader opportunities from the outcome of the RaRE project.

For instance, the scrap separation process that will be developed has applications within both global waste handling and waste handling facility designs. There are also benefits for recycled rare earth production facilities from the models of scrap processing and magnet manufacturing that will be developed, and all these processes and materials will be applicable across several sectors, creating a huge number of opportunities in different applications.

These outcomes from RaRE will present an opportunity to create a competitive advantage for UK motor manufacturing by developing a differentiated supply chain for motors and power electronics, which is expected to grow to £5 billion by 2025. The cost-effective production of magnetic materials could turn the UK into an exporter of magnets for tractions motors and inherently protect the UK from future supply issues. 

Our Solution

The University of Birmingham developed its patented Hydrogen Processing of Magnet Scrap method for use with neodymium iron boron (NdFeB) magnets. This process reduces these types of magnets to a de-magnetised powder that can be mechanically removed from a component. The powder is then purified and remanufactured by resintering, where it is compacted into a solid form using heat or pressure.

This solution allows the extraction of magnets from a wide variety of sources, from automotive products to loudspeakers and hard disk drives, creating immense scale-up opportunities for the project.

AEM are also developing prototype motor designs that have been optimised to use these recycled rare earths whilst meeting the high performance and reliability criteria required by vehicle manufacturers.

Read the RaRE press release: https://advancedelectricmachines.com/new-bentley-motors-project-announcement/

Delivering a compact, integrated, and cost-effective E-Axle with Bentley

AEM’s OCTOPUS project will deliver an E-Axle, free of rare earth materials, that uses next-generation integrated power electronics to create marketing-leading power density and packaging characteristics in line with Bentley’s needs.

We’ve previously worked with Bentley on the APEX motor technology project, and the OCTOPUS project builds on this work by applying leading-edge materials and manufacturing processes to push performance characteristics beyond APEX.


Why?

Delivering the ultimate passenger car E-Axle solution is a challenge that touches many issues: sustainability, rare earth material supply issues, CO2 emissions in production, CO2 emissions in use and recyclability at the end of life.

The key issues to address are four-fold:

  • How do we extract rare earth materials sustainably?
  • How do we put together the materials?
  • How efficiently can we put together these materials?
  • When we’re finished with those materials, how do we make sure we dispose of them in the most sustainable way?


The OCTOPUS Project

The OCTOPUS project sees us apply a cutting-edge approach to an iconic UK brand — and no manufacturer is more demanding than Bentley. But our goal is not simply to narrow its application to best-in-class performance vehicles. This is a technology that can be applied to all vehicles — not just the 0.1%.

The simulation toolkit, test programmes and test rigs can be applied to the automotive and broader transport markets. These can be developed to become vital assets to other automotive organisations leading the development of electrification technologies. The wire production methodology and additive manufacturing process routes developed through the OCTOPUS project will also be suitable for use in the wider component manufacturing market.

Partners on the project include AEM, TTPi, Hieta, Talga, Hartree, Diamond Light Source, University of Bath and Bentley Motors.


The Solution

AEM aims to use everything available in the market in the best way to deliver a world-changing technology solution and push performance characteristics beyond those of the APEX project. The result is an E-Axle solution that is more power-dense, more manufacturable and has stronger performance characteristics.

To achieve this, we used Europe’s largest supercomputer network, one of the world’s largest microscopes and world-leading test and validation. We also brought together the latest carbon-based super materials — graphene and carbon monotube — with traditional materials thinking. The solution has reduced costs and footprint by applying leading-edge materials and manufacturing processes to remove rare earth materials and copper from the process.

From this, we developed a cutting-edge manufacturing process working alongside traditional manufacturing to deliver an integrated solution that reduces the system’s overall manufacturing and assembly costs. The new manufacturing processes can be energy-intensive, and so we only use the technology when necessary. 

By using the installed asset base of the UK’s advanced manufacturing capability, manufacturers don’t have to spend millions on new tech and redesign processes and systems that already deliver low-cost economies. This also helps secure manufacturing jobs in the UK and encourages retraining of employees.

There are also wider opportunities for partners to become involved in developing an end-to-end supply chain, providing an opening for using the technology in sectors beyond automotive. AEM has developed a truly sustainable solution to future transports that is world-leading in its performance, cost and recyclability. 


Keen to learn more? Stay tuned in to find out how it’s going.

More about AEM’s passenger car applications: https://advancedelectricmachines.com/applications/passenger-car/

Read the OCTOPUS press release: https://www.bentleymedia.com/en/newsitem/1128-bentley-motors-looks-to-the-future-of-electric-drive